Cricket-Match-Special ... A forum for discussion

If the supposed £34m fee for Shaw turns out to be true, I think it will be one of those transfers that works out for all parties. If he stayed at Utd his whole remaining career, it would only work out at £2m a season - an absolute snip. Whilst for us, we could do serious transfer business (at our level) with that cash.

Whilst I have no doubt that he will prove himself to be world class, Utd fans are going to bitterly disappointed to start with when they see his appalling crossing.

I think it was you or powelly who said he was a better defender than attacker.

Not been watching the world cup, brendy?

Dr Robert wrote:I think it was you or powelly who said he was a better defender than attacker.

Not been watching the world cup, brendy?

I've certainly said it, yes.

He'll match any right winger in the PL for pace. He wont go to ground unless he knows he'll win the ball. He is seriously strong for a teenager - body of someone much, much older.

But going forward, all he can do right now is run. Can't shoot, can't cross, and his passes seem to be limited to simple one-twos.

st_brendy wrote:

Dr Robert wrote:I think it was you or powelly who said he was a better defender than attacker.

Not been watching the world cup, brendy?

I've certainly said it, yes.

He'll match any right winger in the PL for pace. He wont go to ground unless he knows he'll win the ball. He is seriously strong for a teenager - body of someone much, much older.

But going forward, all he can do right now is run. Can't shoot, can't cross, and his passes seem to be limited to simple one-twos.

Then 34 mil for a full back with those limitations is great buisness for the saints.

st_brendy wrote:

Dr Robert wrote:I think it was you or powelly who said he was a better defender than attacker.

Not been watching the world cup, brendy?

I've certainly said it, yes.

He'll match any right winger in the PL for pace. He wont go to ground unless he knows he'll win the ball. He is seriously strong for a teenager - body of someone much, much older.

But going forward, all he can do right now is run. Can't shoot, can't cross, and his passes seem to be limited to simple one-twos.

I'd rather have a left back that can actually defend like Shaw than someone that can only attack in Evra. If they can attack as well as defend then that's a bonus but too many full backs nowadays are basically wingers who can defend a bit.

dan08 wrote:

st_brendy wrote:

Dr Robert wrote:I think it was you or powelly who said he was a better defender than attacker.

Not been watching the world cup, brendy?

I've certainly said it, yes.

He'll match any right winger in the PL for pace. He wont go to ground unless he knows he'll win the ball. He is seriously strong for a teenager - body of someone much, much older.

But going forward, all he can do right now is run. Can't shoot, can't cross, and his passes seem to be limited to simple one-twos.

I'd rather have a left back that can actually defend like Shaw than someone that can only attack in Evra. If they can attack as well as defend then that's a bonus but too many full backs nowadays are basically wingers who can defend a bit.

Yep, Baines is one. In fact, he can't even defend a "bit".

Hope it is not like when jones and smalling signed and then that was it.

GG - Amir Sohail wrote:Surely a bit worrying for United fans that both Herrera and Shaw were talked about before van Gaal and signed while he's at the World Cup? Like he's had no say at all.

Exactly, the players signing won't have even met him.

SaintPowelly wrote:

GG - Amir Sohail wrote:Surely a bit worrying for United fans that both Herrera and Shaw were talked about before van Gaal and signed while he's at the World Cup? Like he's had no say at all.

Exactly, the players signing won't have even met him.

I'm guessing Giggs will have had a lot of input in this and discussed with the boss probably prior to the WC. Can't see a manager like LVG just accepting the club making signings over his head and telling him to accept it.

Herrera was a deal that fell through 12 months ago, and Shaw was linked well before LVG took over, he was linked under Moyes.

SaintPowelly wrote:Herrera was a deal that fell through 12 months ago, and Shaw was linked well before LVG took over, he was linked under Moyes.

Again probably both were recommended by Giggs. He probably suggested it to Moyes who agreed they'd be good signings.

David Moyes favourite for the Galatasary job.

Lallana to Pool for 25m seems like an amazing deal for the saints.

For United we still need another 2 players at least. CB and a midfielder or winger. Good signs so far. Finally spending the money we need to.

if Giggs had enough sway to spend over 50mil, he would of been made manager, its a director of football deal.

Southampton are likely to sign Pelle soon. Graziano Pelle from Feyenoord that is.