Arthur Crabtree wrote:Ponting made the Aussie team harder to like. Even a lot of Aussie fans were turned off by his leadership.
Indeed. His greatest achievement was arguably beating the Indians in 2007-08, but the conduct he allowed his side to show (and he himself by claiming the catch that never was) consigned the result of the series to a mere footnote. In 2005 his poor sportsmanship left a sour note on a series that had been played very hard and with a certain respect between the teams.
I guess, apart from England's crumbling in 2006-07, and the Aussies victory in South Africa in 2009 (Although South Africa had no Graeme Smith by memory, and Kallis was captain with a downgraded bowling attack), Australia failed to win many big series. He lost 3 out of 4 Ashes series, and the Aussies got beat in India in 2008 and 2010/11. They won in 2004/05 vs India, by memory quite comfortably, but Gilchrist was captain... why he didn't take over permanently was beyond me.
I felt that Ponting always cracked under the pressure a little, either becoming cautious when Australia were put on the back foot, or becoming angry and confrontational. A good example was at Nagpur in 2008, when he hardly bowled his seam attack despite them looking decent, and stuck to part timers rotating.