Red Devil wrote:DiligentDefence wrote:Red Devil wrote:Root's attitude on that catch was ridiculous - it looked out and the fingers were underneath - commentators are sure it was out too but Root's attitude had the crowd booing the umpires decision
I think that is a little harsh. I think it was probably out and certainly there was insufficient evidence to overrule the soft signal but it wasn't clear from the slow motion replay. There was plenty of cheering from England supporters on showing the replay thinking the ball had bounced. That is why they were booing and not necessarily Root's reaction.
Was just listening to the Eng commentator who was saying that he was pretty sure that the Eng suppirters watching the same reply with Root taking the catch would have been sure it was out.
I just think that in the last test (?) Dhawan caught one that looked out but said he wasn't sure so they went through the replays (which are hardly ever conclusive and make most low catches look like the ball may have bounced) and gave it not out. Therefore, given the level of honesty, and the fact that in real time that just looked out, I don't think Root covered himself in glory there in terms of sportsmanship with all the head shaking and bitter muttering as if he'd been horrendously wronged.
andy wrote:Review for another one
Return to Live Cricket Matches
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 90 guests