dan08 wrote:sussexpob wrote:budgetmeansbudget wrote:Is Smalling that bad?
He could be very good, but he has a long way to go. Alex Ferguson loved his defenders to be versatile, but I think Ferguson's way is slightly outdated because full back has become in recent years a very specialist and important role for teams, so you cant expect a guy to play right back one day, cb the next. Jones and Smalling have not developed because they have been asked to chop and change so much. If Van Gaal wants to make Smaliing a CB full time then fine, give him a full season there and he could excel. Don't put either in fake positions though.
Pretty sure Smalling has only played CB this season.
Indeed, but for a 25 year old developing in the game he has asked to play that role by three managers he has worked under, and originally in Van Gaal's system he was playing in a 3 man defence which is an unusual system with different responsibilities.



